Sep 10, 2014
Tomás O'Leary
Tomás O'Leary
Tomás O'Leary

“Bloody, but unbowed” – Invictus.

Forrester Research have written a report on the recent verdict from the District Court of Nevada on the long-running Oracle v. Rimini Street legal case.

If you are not familiar with this prize fight, it was one of the most important legal battles fought between two adversaries; one, at the time in 2010, a $27bn behemoth, and the other a $17m upstart. At stake was the future, and the continued “super” profitability, of the $200bn software maintenance industry, in particular the disruptive version of that maintenance being conducted by the 3SP (third-party support providers) industry.

In January 2010 Oracle sued Rimini Street, a 3SP for Oracle products, claiming they violated Oracle’s licence agreements, committed copyright infringement and violated federal and state laws. Throughout the lawsuit Oracle painted Rimini Street as intellectual property thieves.

Rimini Street, however, hit back, counter claiming for defamation, copyright misuse and unfair competition. After a bruising five year battle Oracle won $50 million in damages from Rimini Street, but that is a long way short (almost 75%) of the crippling damages that Oracle originally sought. The Nevada District Court appears to have rejected Oracle’s claim, made in the original January 2010 court filing, that Rimini Street’s business model “is corrupt”, nor did they agree that it “threatens to cause irreparable harm to Oracle”. Instead, the jury found that Rimini Street’s copyright infringements were “innocent infringements”, and therefore assessed relatively small damages.

In the Forrester report examining the lawsuit and the impact of the verdict on the 3SP industry Duncan Jones notes, “this ultimately bolsters the legitimacy of the basic 3SP business model”, and he further counsels companies to “consider 3SPs within a wider reassessment of your tech suppliers”.

Commenting on the case and the Forrester report, Tomás O’LearyCEO Origina, said, “3SPs like Origina are dedicated to substantially reducing the costs of software support. We hope that the doubters in large companies will realise that they have nothing to fear from software licensors when considering independent 3SPsIn terms of software support the tide has now turned; it is a rising tide for 3SPs and especially their customers.”

In the Forrester report Jones also lists how CIOs have used 3SPs to improve service and stimulate innovation.

Why Read This Brief?

“Over 1,000 companies use third-party support providers (3SPs) such Rimini Street, Spinnaker Support, and Origina. The end of Oracle’s lawsuit against Rimini Street removes some of the fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) that was restricting the market’s growth. Both sides claim victory, but who are the real winners? This brief looks beyond the two companies’ spinning of the verdict and analyzes its immediate implications for CIOs.” – Duncan Jones, Forrester.

“In the fell clutch of circumstance,

I have not winced nor cried aloud.

Under the bludgeonings of chance,

My head is bloody, but unbowed.”

Invictus by William Ernest Henley, 1888.

Recent Posts

IBM/HCL - Breaking News
From the 1st of January 2020, IBM will no longer own or continuing to support Appscan, BigFix, Unica, Commerce, Portal, Lotus Notes & Domino and Connections as they have sold 7 of their legacy software systems to Indian based company, HCL.
Our New German Office
Origina is proud to announce the opening of our new German office to support our DACH expansion.
IBM/HCL - What happens now?
On Tuesday 28th of May, Origina’s CEO, Tomás O’Leary and Martin Thompson from the ITAM Review hosted a webinar in relation to IBM selling a large proportion of their legacy software portfolio to HCL.


Ihr guter Vorsatz fürs neue Jahr – Kosten senken
Verabschieden Sie sich von erzwungenen Upgrades und genießen Sie 2019, glücklich unterstützt von Ihrem Vorsatz fürs neue Jahr.
Wie wirkt sich der Verkauf älterer IBM-Software an HCL auf IBM-Kunden aus?
Wie sich die Übernahme von IBM-Software durch HCL auf bestehende IBM-Kunden auswirken wird
Märchenstunde: 5 „Fakten“ über Software-Audits, die Sie nicht glauben sollten
Um IBM-Audits ranken sich zahlreiche Mythen und Unwahrheiten. Hier sind fünf, die Sie auf keinen Fall glauben sollten.


Votre résolution pour la nouvelle année: réduire les coûts
Dites adieu aux mises à niveau forcées et profitez de 2019 avec le soutien de votre résolution du Nouvel An promise.
À quoi peuvent s’attendre les clients IBM après la vente de ses logiciels hérités à HCL ?
En quoi l’acquisition de logiciels IBM par HCL affectera-t-elle les clients IBM existants ?
Survivre à l’échec d’un audit de licences logicielles
Un jour ou l’autre, votre entreprise échouera à un audit IBM : voici comment survivre à cette défaillance